We are readers supported. When you buy via links on this site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Water Softener Rental – Rent or Buy?

Updated on

So, you need a water softener. If you are sure that in your house hard water is running through your plumbing system, you should have one. But, you are not sure of renting a water softener or buying a water softener - which one is the best choice for you. In the following paras we have exclusively written about water softener rental. But before going to the pros and cons of renting or buying a water softener, for the benefit of our reader who are not sure about hard water issues, here is an introduction to that.

Hard Water and Water Softener

First thing first, what is hard water and do you need a water softener at your home. . You can find out what type of water you have by taking a water hardness test, if your water tests at less than 1 GPG (grains per gallon, 1 grain equals 68.4 milligrams of mineral per gallon), water testing at 1 to 3.5 GPG is slightly hard, 3.5 to 7 is moderately hard and anything above that is extremely hard and will do a lot of damage to plumbing of all sorts in the long run. A water softener is used to remove minerals from the water such as calcium or magnesium, if the water is saturated with them.

Water Softener Rental - Why Should You Rent it?

There are several pros to renting a water softener, one of which is the initial money saving. You can get a custom water softening package you desire for a very small fee compared to the fee you would spend if you bought it right away. This is a good way to test how the device works, if it suits your needs properly - and also gives you a window of time for returning it if it does not suit you at all.

Another pro is that you have virtually no costs for maintenance and repair, all of the costs are covered by your small monthly fee.

You can also ask the supplier to provide you with multiple choices of equipment for you to decide which is the best for your needs, or in case a new model is available you can ask for an upgrade.

And last, you will always have available service for help, maintenance or replacement from the company, as it's in it's best interest to provide a paying customer the highest level of priority.

The Pros of Water Softener Rental

You can avail some great benefits when you choose to rent a system for your home. Some of these benefits include:

A Low Cost: This is one of the biggest reasons why people choose to rent. To buy a new softener, it could cost you nearly $1,000. When you rent, you are avoiding that large payment and making small payments once a month.

Customer Service: It’s a good feeling to know that if something happens to the rental, you are not the one held responsible. The company that you are going through will be able to schedule a time to come and perform maintenance on the machine.

Low Commitment: You have the option of canceling whenever you would like. If you feel like you might be moving in a few years, renting might be the best option for you.

Protection From Changes In The Law: If you are living in a city that might change their mind about allowing this type of appliance, with renting you won’t have to worry about losing money. If they eventually become banned after you buy one, you will be out of a great investment for the machine.

The Cons of Water Softener Rental

Just like anything good in life, there will always be the cons that you have to consider as well. When it comes to renting a treatment system, the cons include:

Pay More In The Long Run: If you are paying $25 to rent a unit, you will have the total cost of a purchased machine paid off in anywhere from 1-4 years, based on the model that you have.

You Have Limited Selection: The company that you are renting through might not give you the largest selection to choose from. If anything, you are going to have your choice amongst some of the cheapest brands.

Equipment Is Older: It’s possible that you are going to be renting a used softener. While repairs are going to be required more often, the machine that you have might not work as well as a new one. This could end up costing you money rather than saving.

Why you should buy a water softener?

Besides the reduced price when comparing the cost of renting versus the cost of buying in the long run, there are several other aspects of buying a water softener to consider.
It adds to the wholesale value of the property - if for instance you are an investor and seek to up the value of the house, getting a water softener is a good way to make it seem more appealing.
While it's a bigger investment than renting the water softener, it's well suited for those who don't plan on moving from the area in which there is hard water.
You can also service it but you'll have to pay for the servicing - but comparing the costs of rental with only the initial cost of buying a water softener, the servicing is a small fraction of the cost running a rental for several years would get you.
It would also be a more probable option to arrange a discount should you buy the water softener with cash, as opposed to buying one on credit. There are several pros and cons to both of these, so you should consider which one is better suited to your needs.

Which one is the Best - Renting or Buying Water Softener?

Consider several things before making a decision - if you are living in an apartment and plan on moving, it's most likely a better option to go for the rental, as long as you make sure it's not on a non-flexible contract. It's also a good idea to check out which model suits you best, even if it means returning the model you have installed for several times if you are using a rental.
A water softener adds to the value of the property, and will reduce the need for more expensive repairs - keep that in mind if you're a landlord. By softening the water, you can prevent serious pipe blockages from happening, saving you plenty of money in the long run.
Those things being said, both have it's pros and cons, for the short run a rental will do just fine, but if you are looking for a long term investment that keeps paying off you are better off buying a water softener and having the firm you bought it from install it.
For the long term solution, you can also get a refund if you decide you don't like it during the trial period, so we would suggest getting the permanent solution - and buying the water softener.

Note: If you are consider to buy a water softener after reading the above exclusive post but don't know which brand or type you should buy, here is the recommended study on best water softener reviews with comparison chart of top 10 water softeners.

You Make The Decision

Now that you understand the pros and cons of renting, the choice that you make is primarily based on what you think is best for your home and the budget that you have. If you don’t have the money to buy, but you can afford to make small monthly payments, renting might be the only choice you can make.

Leave a Comment